CARC

  • News
    • Newsletters
  • Events
  • About
    • The Club
    • Club Profile
    • CARC on The Air
      • The Shack
      • HF
      • VHF
        • VHF DX
    • Contesting
      • Contesting Over the Years
      • CARC / RATS Portable Site
      • VHF/UHF Antennas
    • Training, Exams and Beyond
    • The Committee
    • Our Rules & Constitution
  • The Club
    • Club Profile
    • Archive
  • Join / Renew CARC
  • Find Us
  • Contact Us
  • Apparel

Welcome to Crawley Amateur Radio Club

Latest News ▾
You are here: Home / Uncategorised / How many Radials Do I Need?

How many Radials Do I Need?

5th June 2012 By Crawley ARC Leave a Comment

The following question was posted on the QRPL list a few days ago:

I plan on some portable operations(camping, hiking, etc…) and I was
wondering what are the optimum length of radials for verticals, or
counterpoise for End-fed half waves wires?  Frequencies are 40 through 10
meters (including 30,17, and 12 meters).

I seem to remember something about at least 2 or 3  ¼ wavelengths laid on
the ground.  I just want to get a consensus of the group here about what
seems to work best. 

My response may be of interest to some members of CARC:

I am not sure whether the attachment will make it through the reflector (it’s only 21KB), but it’s worth a look if it does.

It is Fig 30 from Ground System as a Factor in Antenna Efficiency, which is the seminal paper by Brown, Lewis and Epstein published in Proc IRE vol 25, #6 June 1937.

This is the paper where the 200 radial comes from, although they ran out of wire at 113 radials as you can see from the graph.

This shows that with two radials at 1/8 lambda, received field intensity is slightly less 50% down on theoretical maximum. Received power goes as the square of intensity, so two radials are slightly less than 6db down on theoretical maximum, i.e. less than 1 S-point.

If you go up to 15 radial at 1/4 lambda to get to something like 148/196 intensity, i.e. 2.5dB down.

Given that 15 @ 1/4 lambda represents a practical maximum for temporary operation, you have to work pretty hard to win the 3.5 dB relative to the two 1/8 lambda wires.

Two other points of note are that you get within 1dB of maximum with
60 radial at 1/8 lambda and if you go up to 113 radials 1/10 lambda seems to be about 1dB down. However I do worry how accurate the top left corner of the graph is.

I would of course be interested in knowing whether there is later (definitive) evidence that contradicts George Brown’s paper, but the conclusion that very few radial are all this is needed seem startling compare to the advice of the seasoned DX community, which I am sure disheartens operators of ordinary means.

Stewart/G3YSX

Filed Under: Uncategorised

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Upcoming Events

  1. GB70E Special Event Station

    June 26 @ 01:00 - 19:00
  2. RSGB Convention 2022

    October 8 - October 9

View All Events

RECENT POSTS

  • GB70E Special Event Station
  • RSGB Convention 2022
  • CARC Mills on the Air 2022
  • Clubhouse Re opened
  • CARC Zoom Meetings and Club Nets

Contact

    Your Name (required)

    Your Email (required)

    Subject

    Your Message

    Latest News

    GB70E Special Event Station

    12th May 2022 By Mike Davies Leave a Comment

    CARC is pleased to have been granted use of the GB70E special event callsign on SSB for both 19th and 26th of June. We will be operating the club shack on both days and encourage … More

    RSGB Convention 2022

    8th May 2022 By Mike Davies Leave a Comment

    For the first time in three years, the RSGB Convention will be taking place in person over the weekend of 8/9 October. It's open to all so no RSGB membership is required. The … More

    CARC Mills on the Air 2022

    25th April 2022 By Mike Davies Leave a Comment

    CARC will be taking part in the Mill on the Air event on Sunday 8th May. We will be establishing an HF station at the Ifield Mill operating as GB0IWM (Ifield WindMill). If … More

    Clubhouse Re opened

    30th January 2022 By Phil Moore Leave a Comment

    As of Sunday 13th February 2022 the Clubhouse resumes normal operations and is open for Sunday and Wednesday meetings. The Committee will continuously monitor the situation going … More

    CARC Resume Meetings at Hut18

    15th September 2021 By Mike Davies Leave a Comment

    The committee met last night via Zoom and top of our agenda was restarting the twice-weekly meetings at Hut18.  Since the last national lockdown restrictions were removed some … More

    Stewart Bryant G3YSX Elected RSGB President

    24th April 2021 By Mike Davies Leave a Comment

    Congratulations to our own Stewart G3YSX on his election to the position of RSGB President. More to follow... … More

    Our Location

    We meet on Wednesday evenings 20:00 to 22:00 approx. and Sunday mornings 11:00 to 13:30 approx. at our dedicated radio shack Hut 18 in Tilgate Forest Recreational Area. near K2

    Tap here for a map.

    Flag Counter

    Copyright © 2022 Crawley Amateur Radio Club · Log in